Generation Why: True Crime

This episode examines the 1997 murder of Anastasia Whitzlfeugen in Kansas City, focusing on the conviction of her friend Byron Case.

This episode examines the rise of self-help guru James Arthur Ray, whose charismatic seminars promised wealth and enlightenment to thousands of followers.

Hosts Aaron and Justin discuss two contrasting true crime cases.

This episode details the 2018 quadruple murder of Keith Canaro and his family by his brother, Paul.

This episode covers the 2017 kidnapping of Connie and Larry Van Oosten by Chad Shipper, their former financial advisor.

This episode covers the second trial of Mark Lundy for the murders of his wife and daughter, focusing on the prosecution’s shifted narrative regarding the time of death.

Hosts Aaron and Justin discuss the legal appeals of Mark Lundy, convicted of murdering his wife and daughter.

This episode continues the Mark Lundy murder case, focusing on his 2002 trial and the Crown’s key evidence.

Hosts Aaron and Justin introduce a four-part series on the 2000 murders of Christine and Amber Lundy in New Zealand.

Generation Why: True Crime investigates the 1997 Dunbar Armored heist, one of the largest robberies in US history.

This episode details the 1946 X-ray Camera Case, where unemployed Pearl Lusk was manipulated by Alphonse Rocco into shooting his estranged wife, Olga, on a NYC subway.

This episode examines the suspicious 2014 death of attorney Abe DiBella, whose body was found in a rollover crash with a gunshot wound to the head.

This episode previews three distinct true crime and investigative series.

Hosts Aaron and Justin investigate the 1980 Rendlesham Forest UFO incident, often called Britain’s Roswell.

This episode examines the controversial case of Nicky Ademando, who was convicted of murdering her partner, Christopher Grover, after years of alleged domestic abuse.

Hosts Aaron and Justin discuss the 2010 disappearance of Joanne Matouk Romain, whose body was found months later in the Detroit River.

Vinny Paladino of Court TV discusses the evolution of his show and analyzes high-profile cases, including the Abby Zwirner school shooting and the Mackenzie Shirilla crash.

Hosts Aaron and Justin investigate the 2013 disappearance of college student Bryce LaSpisa, who vanished after a single-vehicle accident near Lake Castaic.

This episode examines the 1986 deaths of two boys found in a burning shed in Texas and the subsequent conviction of their stepfather, Edward Graff.

This episode examines the 2007 murder of Jody Perrick in Michigan, focusing on the wrongful perjury conviction of reserve officer Ray McCann.

Hosts Justin and Aaron examine the 2001 anthrax attacks, detailing the deaths of five people and the widespread fear following 9/11.

This episode details the murder of Michael Cochran by his wife, Natalie, a pharmacist who ran a $2.

In this episode of Generation Why, hosts Aaron and Justin discuss part two of the Sodder Children mystery, focusing on the family’s decades-long…

Generation Why investigates the 1945 Sodder family fire, featuring an interview with great-great-granddaughter Miranda Sauter to correct historical misinformation.

This episode examines the tragic 2025 murders of Mary Jingles, her father, and a neighbor by her abusive husband, Nathan Jingles.

Hosts Aaron and Justin investigate the McDonald’s Monopoly scam, where security director Jerome Jacobson stole winning game pieces and sold them to accomplices.

This episode examines the 2000 disappearance of Indiana University student Jill Behrman, whose remains were found in 2003.