Generation Why: True Crime Generation Why: True Crime

LISTEN NOW: The First Wife

Nov 9, 2026 · 9m

Summary

This episode introduces Tanya Bales, the first wife of serial killer John Meehan, recounting their initial meeting at a bar in 1988. Tanya describes her hesitation and eventual decision to go home with John, leading to a sexual encounter she later regrets. The narrative also features a modern-day twist where her daughter receives a message from a potential half-brother, highlighting the enduring impact of Meehan's legacy on the family.

Topics discussed

Introduction to The First Wife podcast Host Rachel Louise Snyder's background Tanya Bales' decision to tell her story Daughter Abigail's discovery of a potential half-brother Reflections on John Meehan's lasting impact Tanya's work life and the night she met John First encounter at Shooters bar The drink order and age discrepancy John's request for a ride home Entering John's house and the first night Tanya's regret and morning after John's follow-up and the start of dating Audible subscription promotion

More from Generation Why: True Crime

Lost Boys of Pickering - 710
Nov 15, 2026
Under Wraps - 7002
Nov 8, 2026
Where Are Amber Aiaz & Melissa Fu? - 708
Nov 2, 2026
Eastern State Penitentiary - 707
Oct 25, 2026
Strange Stories - The Flannan Isles Lighthouse Mystery - 706
Oct 21, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria