This episode investigates the 2006 death of Carrie Baker, a Texas teacher whose suicide was later ruled undetermined after her family uncovered her husband Matt's history of sexual misconduct. The hosts detail how Matt, a pastor with a pattern of harassment, allegedly murdered Carrie by suffocation and drug overdose, supported by evidence of his affair with another woman and suspicious internet searches. The story highlights the failure of church and law enforcement authorities to act on prior allegations, leading to a wrongful death lawsuit and Matt's eventual arrest for murder.
Listen ad-free on Castria