A Private Matter, Episode 5
Nov 11, 2026 · 47m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode of Bear Brook, titled "A Private Matter," investigates the 2023 disappearance of John Hickey from his New Hampshire farm. Reporter Jason Moon examines the police interrogation of Hickey’s wife, Patty, who maintained her husband simply walked away, despite evidence suggesting she failed to report his missing status for months. The story contrasts Patty’s calm, dismissive demeanor with her daughters’ allegations of abuse and suspicion of foul play, ultimately questioning the boundaries of responsibility in a case with no definitive resolution.
Topics discussed
Intro to National Park After Dark and transition to the story
Context for the final interrogation of Patty Hickey
Lieutenant Flanders introduces himself and the polygraph
Interrogation: Timeline, denial, and holiday questions
Interrogation tactics: Flattery and the 'Redemption Road'
Confrontational phase: Accusations of inaction
The nursing home theory emerges
Conclusion of the police interrogation
Sponsor: Vinted
Promo: Free Shelly Jensen
Promo: New Hampshire Public Radio and Bear Brook
Reporter's approach to interviewing Patty
Patty and Jay's meeting and early marriage
Jay's dementia and Patty's assessment of his state
Patty's changing story about Jay's disappearance
The privacy argument and potential assisted suicide
Patty's denial of responsibility and likability
Daughters' accusations and Patty's reaction
Analysis of Patty's behavior and the mystery
Tour of the farm and Patty's current life
The barn as a shrine to Jay and closing thoughts
Credits and additional promotions
More from Bear Brook
Listen ad-free on Castria