A Private Matter, Episode 4
Nov 4, 2026 · 45m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode explores the stalled investigation into Jay Hickey’s disappearance, highlighting the legal inability to charge his wife, Patty, for failing to report him missing. It details a disturbing phone call where Patty allegedly confessed to a former babysitter that she found Jay dead near an old foundation, leading to a fruitless police search. The narrative also examines the science of searching for missing individuals with dementia and the emotional toll on the family, who sought closure through a medium.
Topics discussed
Rob Hickey joins the call with a medium
The medium senses Jay's absence and energy
Rob and Sandra share details with the medium
Medium confirms foul play and money motive
Medium claims to receive a message from Jay
Rob reflects on the medium's message and closure
Chief Michael's frustration with the investigation
Chief Michael's personal connection to Jay
Legal issues: No crime for not reporting missing
New Hampshire neglect laws and their limitations
Why Patty cannot be charged with Jay's death
Jay's legal status: Not officially dead yet
Investigation suspended; Chief Michael haunted
Kay Danko's spiritual search and family history
Kay's past warning to Jay about Patty
The difficulty of accepting a natural death
Kathy O'Meara calls Kay with a new lead
Patty's voicemail to Kathy about Jay's death
Kathy's notes: Patty claims finding Jay dead
Kathy urges Patty to tell the children the truth
Kathy reports the confession to the police
Police search the old foundation in winter
Waiting for snow to melt for a proper search
Spring search yields no results; Patty's story shifts
Confusion and suspicion remain after the search
Consulting Robert Kester, a search and rescue expert
Behavioral patterns of lost people and dementia
Data on lost people with dementia in wilderness
Types of dementia wandering and getting stuck
Search radius data: 1.2 miles for dementia cases
Feasibility of searching the 1.2-mile radius
Review of police search efforts and resources
Fish and Game's perspective on search costs
Resource allocation and the value of life
Survivability rates and the difficulty of finding remains
Decomposition and the likelihood of finding bones
Reflections on whether enough was done to find Jay
Host's personal search in the woods
Credits and final thoughts on the case
More from Bear Brook
Listen ad-free on Castria