A Private Matter, Episode 1
Oct 21, 2026 · 26m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode of *Bear Brook* investigates the mysterious disappearance of Jay Hickey, a 76-year-old man with dementia who vanished from his New Hampshire Christmas tree farm. The story centers on his wife, Patty, a longtime town welfare officer, whose calm demeanor and inconsistent timeline regarding Jay’s absence raised suspicions among neighbors and investigators. Through interviews with community members and analysis of police interrogations, the report explores the strange circumstances surrounding the case, questioning whether Jay wandered off or if other factors are involved.
Topics discussed
Introduction to Epsom, NH and the Christmas tree farm
Local memories of the farm and the drive up the mountain
Introducing Patty and Jay Hickey and their civic roles
Jay's passion for trees and the couple's family life
Jay's diagnosis with dementia and Patty as caretaker
Challenges of balancing town duties with caregiving
Jay's wandering incidents and growing community concern
Jay's disappearance and the five-month timeline gap
Patty's suspiciously normal behavior at a candidate forum
Kathy O'Mara's visit and Patty's evasive calmness
Sponsor breaks and show updates
Jason Moon's initial skepticism and investigation start
Patty's police interrogation: setting and initial chat
Patty's account of Jay leaving to visit his brothers
Police questioning Patty on her lack of contact with Jay
Patty's justification for not reporting him missing sooner
Jason's reaction to the bizarre story and emerging mystery
Community speculation and the search for answers
Credits and closing sponsor reads
More from Bear Brook
Listen ad-free on Castria