A Private Matter, Episode 3
Oct 28, 2026 · 39m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode explores the disappearance of Jay Hickey by investigating the profound influence of his grandmother, a famous 1970s astrologer, on his life and spirituality. The narrative follows retired cop Joe Murphy’s unconvincing theory that Jay’s wife and neighbors conspired to kill him for financial gain, while also examining suspicious activities by his wife, Patty, such as depositing Jay’s checks and sending odd texts from his phone.
Topics discussed
Sponsors and Radio Renzo horror teaser
Introduction to Jay Hickey's disappearance
Meeting Joe Murphy and his connection to Jay
Profile of Isabella Hickey, the astrologer
Jay's childhood and the book 'Never Mind'
Jay's spiritual beliefs and buying the farm
Patty's use of Izzy's teachings during investigation
Sponsors: Nordstrom Rack, Pfizer, In the Dark
Introduction to Amy Shapiro, co-author and student
Amy's suspicious interactions with Patty
Joe Murphy's theory of conspiracy to commit homicide
The sale of the Christmas tree farm
Evidence of Jay's declining mental state
Suicide threat and questions of sound mind
Analysis of Joe's theory and police response
Reflections on Jay's character and next steps
Credits and final sponsor reads
More from Bear Brook
Listen ad-free on Castria