A Private Matter, Episode 2
Oct 21, 2026 · 42m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode of Bear Brook investigates the 2024 disappearance of Jay Hickey, a man with advanced dementia in Epsom, New Hampshire. It explores the complex family dynamics, including Emily Hickey’s revelations of her mother Patty’s mental illness and past abuse, which cast a shadow over Jay’s final months. The narrative details how Patty allegedly told police and neighbors Jay was visiting a brother, despite evidence suggesting he vanished ten months prior.
Topics discussed
Introduction and the Epsom community Facebook group
Jay Hickey goes missing and family questions
Emily Hickey describes her mother's abuse
The incident where Patty shot the family dog
Jay's character and Emily's path to forgiveness
Jay's dementia and Emily's final contact
Explaining dementia and Alzheimer's disease
Emily discovers Jay is missing from the farm
Emily reports Jay missing to the police
Police investigate Patty's claim that Jay is in Florida
Police visit the farm and find the house hoarded
Police search the property and find no trace of Jay
Timeline reveals Jay was missing for 10 months
Colleagues recall Patty's story about Jay visiting a brother
Coworker Andrea Novotny describes Patty's behavior
Adult Protective Services and the dignity of risk
Police find Patty collected Jay's Social Security
Chief Michael interrogates Patty about Jay's disappearance
Teaser for next episode and show credits
More from Bear Brook
Listen ad-free on Castria