Cruel and Unusual UPDATED
Nov 18, 2026 · 54m
More History podcasts
Summary
This episode revisits the 2016 story of Maya Foa, who exposed a global network of pharmaceutical companies supplying lethal injection drugs to the U.S., and examines how the resulting drug shortages have led to botched executions and a return to firing squads. Host Matt Kilty and reporter Karen Duffin discuss the Eighth Amendment implications of these methods, featuring insights from legal scholar Carol Steiker and death row survivor Damien Eccles. The conversation reflects on the evolving national debate over the constitutionality and morality of capital punishment in the modern era.
Topics discussed
Introduction and context for the episode
Recent news: botched execution and firing squad announcement
Introducing the story and key figures
Maya Foer's initial mission to trace the drug supplier
The mystery pharmacy and the stayed execution
The global journey and Supreme Court attention
The nationwide shortage of sodium thiopental
Tracing the supply chain and finding the invoice
Visiting the Elgon Driving Academy and Dream Pharma
Interview with the supplier and EU export controls
Global pharmaceutical companies refusing to supply
Radiolab promotional segment
Bill Wiseman's background and political career
The reinstatement of the death penalty in 1976
The creation of the lethal injection protocol
Wiseman's regret and the purpose of each drug
The constitutional importance of the anesthetic
DIY execution methods and botched executions
Supreme Court debate on drug availability
Debating the cruelty of new execution methods
Utah's return to the firing squad
Public reaction to the firing squad
Witness accounts of firing squad executions
Volunteers for the firing squad
Training and selection of firing squad members
Prayers and mindset of the shooters
Criticism of lethal injection as a method
Justice Breyer's call to reconsider the death penalty
Declining death sentences and reasons why
Legal and financial barriers to the death penalty
Abolition in 23 states and wrongful convictions
Damien Eccles' experience on death row
Mixed feelings and perspectives from death row
Attempts to drop appeals and desire for execution
Critique of the legal machinery and bureaucracy
Arbitrariness in sentencing and external pressures
Geographic and racial disparities in death penalty
The clarifying nature of lived experience
Impact of witnessing violence in prison
Public consciousness and fractured opinions
The pendulum swing between justice and mercy
Credits and acknowledgments
More from More Perfect
Listen ad-free on Castria