No More Souters - Revisited
Summary
This episode of More Perfect explores the legacy of the late Justice David Souter, known for his privacy and unexpected liberal rulings. Hosts Julia Longoria and Gabrielle Bourbet interview former clerks and biographers to discuss how Souter’s confirmation by George H.W. Bush sparked the "No More Souters" movement, which transformed Supreme Court nominations. The episode details his pivotal role in preserving Roe v. Wade in Planned Parenthood v. Casey and how his judicial philosophy emphasized stability and precedent.
Topics discussed
Introduction: The death of Justice David Souter and his elusive persona
Souter's personality: Reclusive habits, apple-eating, and clerk anecdotes
The Bork nomination: A cautionary tale for the Republican Party
Souter's confirmation: Vague answers and the 'Stare Decisis' dodge
Planned Parenthood v. Casey: Souter upholds Roe v. Wade
The 'No More Souters' era: Changing nomination strategies
Legacy: Souter's impact on the Court and modern judicial politics
Listen ad-free on Castria