More Perfect More Perfect

Andy Warhol and the Art of Judging Art

Aug 3, 2023 · 41m

Summary

In this season finale, host Julia Longoria examines the Supreme Court case Andy Warhol Foundation v. Goldsmith, which challenged the "transformative use" standard in copyright law. The episode traces the legal history from Judge Pierre LaValle’s influential theory to the Two Live Crew parody case, before analyzing the Court’s 7-2 ruling favoring photographer Lynn Goldsmith. Through interviews with art critic Jerry Saltz and legal experts, the show explores whether judicial interpretation of art resembles objective engineering or subjective criticism.

Topics discussed

Intro and listener support appeal The Andy Warhol vs. Goldsmith case overview History of fair use and Judge Pierre LaValle Two Live Crew parody case and transformative use Background: Prince photo and Warhol's silkscreen Supreme Court oral arguments on transformative meaning The Supreme Court's decision and reasoning Dissenting opinion and legal criticism Art criticism vs. legal standards Season finale wrap-up and credits

More from More Perfect

The Harvard Plan
Nov 18, 2025
No More Souters - Revisited
May 9, 2025
The Original Anti-Vaxxer
Jul 27, 2023
Not Even Past: Dred Scott Reprise
Jul 20, 2023
Listen ad-free on Castria