Case 357: Wayne & Sharmon Stock
Nov 14, 2026 · 1h 21m
More True Crime podcasts · More History podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the 2006 double homicide of Wayne and Sharman Stock in rural Nebraska, focusing on the controversial conviction of intellectually disabled suspect Matt Livers and his cousin Nick Sampson. The narrative highlights the police’s reliance on coerced confessions and polygraph tests, which contradicted physical evidence and alibis. It also details the discovery of DNA linking the crime to teenagers Gregory Fester and Jessica Reed, whose accounts were largely ignored by investigators committed to their initial theory.
Topics discussed
Intro: Jane Doe and the First Wife podcast
Sponsor: Audible and youth mental health
Sponsor: Gabb phones for kids
Easter 2006: The Stock family's last day
Discovery of Wayne Stock's body
Discovery of Sharman Stock and crime scene clues
Community shock and the victims' reputation
Suspect Matt Livers and family tensions
Initial police interview of Matt Livers
The tan sedan and Will Sampson's car cleaning
Matt Livers' background and relationship with Sarah
Coercive interrogation and Matt's false confession
Sponsors: Faire and Gusto
Arrest of Nick Sampson and discovery of shotgun
Inconsistencies in confession and blood in Will's car
The gold ring and tracing Corey Zastrow
The Wisconsin teens: Greg Fester and Jessica Reed
Jessica's diary and conflicting suspect accounts
Investigation of Tom Todd and DNA evidence
Sponsor: Vinted
Ryan Paulding's false confession and release of Nick
Nick Sampson's release and Matt's continued detention
Discovery of hidden recording and Matt's recantation
Matt Livers' release and the Reed Technique
The true crime: Greg and Jessica's confession
David Kofod's evidence tampering and trial
Kofod's sentencing and civil settlements
The Reed Technique and interrogation reform
Reflection on the victims and the teens' actions
Sponsor: Lowe's Black Friday deals
More from Casefile True Crime
Listen ad-free on Castria