Casefile Extra: Chad Shelton & Duane Johnson
Oct 24, 2026 · 1h 6m
More True Crime podcasts · More History podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the 1978 deaths of an infant and his uncle in Omaha, Nebraska, which were initially misdiagnosed as a mysterious illness. Investigators uncover a link to a toxic substance and a former partner, Stephen Harper, who had a history of violence and access to laboratory chemicals. The story details the forensic investigation that identifies Harper as the killer, who confessed to poisoning the victims with a carcinogen to exact revenge on his ex-girlfriend.
Topics discussed
Sponsorships and introduction to the youth mental health crisis
Content warnings and crisis support resources
The Shelton family falls ill after a strange dinner
Chad's rapid deterioration and hospitalization
Chad's death and Dwayne Johnson's collapse
Dwayne's symptoms and the connection to the first case
Hospital isolation and the search for a common cause
Autopsy results and public health investigation
Identifying the lemonade as the source of poisoning
Confirmation of the toxic link and initial relief
Sponsor segments for Cozy, Gusto, and Gymshark
Police involvement and launch of criminal investigation
Interrogating the families and suspecting Sandra Johnson
Surveillance of Sandra and lack of direct evidence
Sandra's past relationships and volatile history
Discovery of the shooting incident involving Stephen Harper
The 1975 shooting incident and Harper's arrest
Harper's imprisonment and the mystery of his whereabouts
Tracing Harper's movements and the Epley Institute connection
Forensic analysis of liver tissue and identifying the toxin
Investigating the Epley Institute and Stephen Harper's role
Evidence of animal poisoning and vet testimony
Sponsor segment for Stamps.com
Confirming animal deaths and ruling out Sandra's guilt
Media frenzy and locating Stephen Harper in Texas
Harper's arrest and coerced confession
Harper's account of the poisoning and chemical identification
Toxicology analysis and the challenge of proving DMN
Testimony from Bill Trout and Harper's motive
Sandra's testimony and the prosecution's strategy
Trial proceedings and Harper's death sentence
Civil lawsuit against the Epley Institute and precedent cases
Long-term consequences for the victims and Harper's fate
Closing sponsor segment for Gymshark
More from Casefile True Crime
Listen ad-free on Castria