Casefile True Crime Casefile True Crime

Case 355: Anna Lisa Raymundo

Oct 31, 2026 · 1h 25m

Summary

This episode details the 2002 murder of pharmaceutical researcher Annalisa Ramundo in Stamford, Connecticut, and the subsequent investigation that initially focused on her boyfriend, Nelson Sessler. The narrative shifts to reveal the true killer, Sheila Davalu, who murdered her husband Paul using a candle while he was blindfolded and handcuffed during a game. The story explores how Sheila’s obsession with a workplace love triangle involving Annalisa and her husband’s infidelity led to the fatal confrontation, ultimately exposing the dark secrets within their marriage.

Topics discussed

Introduction to the case of Jane Doe Sponsor: Citizens Bank The frantic 911 call to Stanford Police Police arrive at the wrong address Discovery of Annalisa Raimundo's body Annalisa's life and final voicemail Parents learn of the murder Witnesses and initial suspect screening Nelson Sessler questioned at the scene Nelson's shifting alibi and request for lawyer Autopsy details and murder weapon analysis Investigation stalls and surveillance at wake Case goes cold for four months Unrelated incident: Man injured in condo Sponsor: Home Chef Sponsor: Gymshark Sponsor: Serval Paul and Sheila's relationship and marriage Strain in marriage and hiding Paul's presence Sheila's stories about a workplace love triangle Providing surveillance equipment to 'Melissa' News of Annalisa's murder and fading stories Sheila's brother's breakdown and unexplained pills The blindfold game and initial injury Paul's worsening condition and false 911 call Drive to hospital and second stabbing Struggle for survival and Paul's escape Paul's surgery and Sheila's arrest Sponsors: Vinted and Serval Detectives investigate Sheila and Nelson's link Nelson's relationship with Sheila and Annalisa Revealing the true identities in the love triangle Identifying Sheila as the 911 caller Timeline reconstruction and physical evidence Discovery of diet pills and taser Sheila's trial for attempted murder DNA evidence links Sheila to Annalisa's condo Plea deal and trial preparation for murder Murder trial testimony and motive Guilty verdict for Annalisa's murder Sentencing and family statements Sheila's appeals and mental health claims Annalisa's legacy and family memories Sponsor: Gymshark Sponsor: Serval

More from Casefile True Crime

Case 358: The Beltway Snipers (Part 1/2)
Nov 20, 2026
Case 357: Wayne & Sharmon Stock
Nov 14, 2026
Case 356: Lesley Howell & Trevor Buchanan
Nov 7, 2026
Casefile Presents: Ada
Oct 26, 2026
Casefile Extra: Chad Shelton & Duane Johnson
Oct 24, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria