Case 349: Michael Wallace & David Castor
Summary
This episode details the suspicious deaths of Stacey Castor’s two husbands, Michael Wallace and David Castor, both found to have died from antifreeze poisoning. Investigators grew suspicious of Stacey’s behavior and the staged crime scenes, leading to the exhumation of Michael’s body, which confirmed poisoning. The case takes a shocking turn when Stacey’s daughter, Ashley, is found in a drug-induced coma with a forged suicide note confessing to the murders to protect her mother.
Topics discussed
Intro, sponsorships, and content warning
David Castor's erratic behavior and discovery of his body
Stacey's account, family tensions, and antifreeze poisoning details
Forensic evidence, the will, and suspicion of foul play
Sponsor breaks and transition to Stacey's first marriage
Stacey's relationship with Michael Wallace and his sudden death
Exhumation reveals Michael was also poisoned with antifreeze
Ashley's apparent suicide attempt and the confessional note
Ashley's hospitalization and the staged nature of the incident
Digital evidence proving Stacey wrote the suicide note
Stacey's arrest and the mother-versus-daughter defense strategy
Trial testimony from Ashley, Bree, and Stacey Castor
Verdict, sentencing, and victim impact statements
Psychological analysis, prison life, and final sponsorships
Listen ad-free on Castria