Casefile True Crime Casefile True Crime

Case 354: The Gilgo Beach Serial Killings (Part 2/2)

Oct 3, 2026 · 1h 40m

Summary

This episode investigates the Gilgo Beach serial killings, focusing on the corruption of former Suffolk County Police Chief James Burke, who was convicted for assaulting a suspect and obstructing justice. The narrative details how Burke’s political ties and exclusion of the FBI stalled the case for years until a new task force digitized files and identified Rex Huwerman as the killer. Investigators linked Huwerman to the victims through cell tower data, a distinctive vehicle, and DNA evidence, leading to his arrest in 2023.

Topics discussed

Sponsors and podcast promotions Christopher Loeb's arrest and police misconduct Internal politics and the 97% confession rate James Burke's scandal and cell tower data Burke's tenure and the Loeb assault investigation Leanne's allegations and public speculation Narrowing the suspect list and Jane Doe 6 ID The leather belt clue and case file digitization Home Chef sponsorship segment Plot Thickens podcast promotion Dave Schaller's witness account and buried tip Rex Heilman's background and childhood Marriage to Asa and home renovations Task force investigation and phone records Digital evidence and DNA matches Arrest, home raid, and basement discovery Charges, deleted documents, and planning lists Vinted sponsorship segment Jessica Taylor and Valerie Mack connections Sandra Castilla and early 90s timeline Karen Viggada and victim identification Peaches, Tanya, and Shannon Gilbert's case Plea deal negotiations and family meetings Confession details and sentencing Victim families' statements and legacy

More from Casefile True Crime

Case 358: The Beltway Snipers (Part 1/2)
Nov 20, 2026
Case 357: Wayne & Sharmon Stock
Nov 14, 2026
Case 356: Lesley Howell & Trevor Buchanan
Nov 7, 2026
Case 355: Anna Lisa Raymundo
Oct 31, 2026
Casefile Presents: Ada
Oct 26, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria