The Suitcase Murders
Oct 17, 2026 · 1h 26m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the investigation into the discovery of two women's bodies in suitcases on a Wisconsin roadside, linking the case to the disappearance of Laura Simonson in Minnesota. Investigators uncover that the suspect, former police officer Stephen Zelich, had been communicating with the victims on a BDSM dating site. The story follows the forensic breakthroughs, including DNA evidence from rope and hotel surveillance, that led to Zelich's arrest and his subsequent confession to the murders.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Carvana
Discovery of suitcases containing bodies in Geneva, WI
Initial investigation and victim identification challenges
Statewide search for missing persons
Introduction to Laura Simonson's disappearance in Minnesota
Laura's background, family, and personal struggles
The disappearance and the mysterious note from Jeff Madison
Investigation into Laura's online BDSM activities
Sponsors: Audible, Wayfair, Mint Mobile
Tracing Laura's movements to a hotel in Rochester, MN
Identifying the suspect: Mr. Handcuffs
Background of suspect Stephen Zellich, former police officer
FBI involvement and the case going cold
Connecting the Wisconsin victims to Laura Simonson
DNA evidence and confirming Zellich as the prime suspect
Preparing to confront the suspect
Sponsors: Shopify, NoCD
Search of Zellich's apartment and initial interview
Zellich's confession and identification of second victim Jenny Gomez
Jenny Gomez's background and relationship with Zellich
Reconstruction of Jenny's murder and storage in refrigerator
Reconstruction of Laura's murder and disposal of bodies
Abandoning the suitcases and the suspect's alibi
Sponsors: Shopify, Mint Mobile, Carvana
Interrogation: Debating accidental death vs. murder
Charges, plea deal, and sentencing
Aftermath, family impact, and search for other victims
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria