The After Show: Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County Girls
Nov 16, 2026 · 27m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
Investigative journalist Paul Solitaroff and survivor Sarah discuss the unsolved disappearances of two girls in Carmel, New York, and the wrongful convictions of Anthony DePippo and Andrew Krivak. Sarah shares her traumatic experience being sexually assaulted by Howard Gombert, who was later cited as an alternate suspect in the murder case. The episode highlights the overturned convictions and the ongoing call for a special prosecutor to investigate Gombert’s potential involvement in the deaths.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Upwork
Intro: Disappearances in Carmel, NY
Paul Solitaroff's investigation origins
Robin Murphy's background and disappearance
Unsolved case and psychic leads
Josette Wright's remains and staging details
Eyewitness testimony and forensic doubts
Prison conditions and self-education
Sponsor: Proper Hills
Promo: Cold-Blooded podcast
Return: Introduction of witness Sarah
Sarah's account of childhood assault
Trauma, silence, and Gombert's conviction
Sarah's role in the DiPippo trial
Gombert's impending release and Sarah's anger
Sponsor: Dancing with the Stars Podcast
Paul's phone interview with Gombert
DA statement and call for special prosecutor
Outro and resources
Sponsors: Honda and All's Fair
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria