Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County School Girls
Nov 14, 2026 · 1h 26m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
Host Paul Solotaroff investigates the unsolved 1995 disappearance of 17-year-old Robin Murphy in Carmel, New York, and its connection to the 1994 murder of 12-year-old Josette Wright. The episode details the wrongful conviction of Anthony DePippo and the subsequent discovery that laundromat attendant Howard Gombert, the last person to see Robin, was a serial offender who possessed Robin’s DNA. It concludes with the ongoing search for Robin’s remains in the Tilly Foster mine.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Odoo all-in-one business management software
Introduction: The Tilly Foster mine and the search for Robin
Background: Robin Murphy's life and personality
The last known evening: ShopRite, Burger King, and the laundromat
The disappearance: April 9, 1995, and the initial police response
Investigation: Suspects, journals, and the feeling of being tailed
The answering machine message and early search efforts
Ralph Jones: The diver who first investigated the case
The Josette Wright case: Disappearance in 1994
Discovery of Josette's remains in the woods
Connecting the two cases: Public panic and media attention
The suspects: Anthony DePippo and Andy Krivak
Denise Rose's testimony and the initial arrests
The trial: Prosecution's case and graphic testimony
Defense arguments: Lack of physical evidence and the van
Wrongful conviction: Anthony DePippo's imprisonment
New leads: Howard Gombert and allegations of sexual assault
Prison confessions: Joe Santoro and Gombert's alleged admissions
Victim testimonies: Jane and Sarah's accounts of Gombert's abuse
DNA evidence: Gombert's arrest and the search of his home
Gombert as a suspect in Robin's disappearance
The retrial: Gombert's testimony and Sarah's account
The verdict: Anthony DePippo found not guilty
Aftermath: Andy Krivak's release and the community's reaction
Psychic mediums and the search in the Tilly Foster mine
Diving the mine: Finding boots and the hope for closure
DNA results: Remains do not match Robin Murphy
Confronting Gombert: His denial and ongoing legal battles
Conclusion: Remembering Josette and Robin, and the next case
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria