Murder on the Menu
Nov 21, 2026 · 1h 25m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the unsolved double homicide of Tom and Angela Strushan, owners of the Salsa Joe’s Tex-Mex Smokehouse in Belmont County, Ohio, who were shot and killed in a staged house fire. Investigators initially pursued leads involving extortion by a former employee and Tom’s extramarital affairs, but the case remained cold for years. The narrative shifts focus to Andrew Griffin, a former business partner who had financial disputes with the couple, as detectives uncover new evidence linking him to the crime.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Deadly Nightmares podcast
Introduction to Tom and Angela Strushan
The house fire and initial discovery
Background on the victims and Salsa Joe's
Reactions to the news and early investigation
Personalities of Tom and Angela
Suspicious fire and double homicide declaration
How Tom and Angela met and started the business
Running Salsa Joe's and moving to Ohio
Employee memories and the discovery of bodies
Forensic challenges due to fire and water
Investigating the fire origins and entry point
Early suspects and the blackmail lead
The extortion scheme by Miana and Anthony
Details of the blackmail and payments
Interrogation of blackmailers and their sentencing
Investigation of Tom's extramarital affairs
Sponsors: Proper Hills and Equip
Scrutinizing the marriage and Angela's knowledge
Questioning Tom's affairs and Angela's awareness
Investigating Angela's financial contributions
Rumors of mob connections and past bribery
Frustration with lack of leads
Reward offers and public appeals
Private investigations and old-school methods
New momentum and Tom's sister's tribute
Introduction of partner Andrew Griffin
Griffin's investment and the new location
Griffin's disappearance and lack of income
Attempts to contact Griffin and phone records
Sponsors: Wayfair and Mint Mobile
Subpoenaing records and Griffin's flight
Griffin in Costa Rica and divorce details
Detectives' travel to Oklahoma
Stacy Griffin's confession and fear
Details on the weapon and motorcycle
Identifying Brett Cole and the motorcycle sale
Tracing the motorcycle and social media leads
Breakthrough with Brett Cole's social media
Conversation with motorcycle seller Corey White
Photographic evidence of the motorcycle
Tracking the burner phone purchase
Matching the phone to the crime scene
Arrest of Andrew Griffin
Griffin's return to Ohio and arrest announcement
Sponsors: Shopify and Equip
The trial begins
Defense arguments and family testimony
Prosecution's financial motive theory
The burner phone anomaly
Tracking the phone's movement
Linking Griffin to the motorcycle
Defense claims of conspiracy without Griffin
Brett Cole's testimony begins
Cole describes the plan and alibi
Details of the shooting and robbery setup
Defense challenges Cole's credibility
Cole's testimony on Griffin's confession
Defense case and Griffin's behavior
Closing arguments and jury deliberation
Verdict: Guilty of aggravated murder
Reactions to the verdict
Family reflections on justice
Remembering Angela's personality
Sponsor: Wayfair Black Friday
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria