True Crime Vault: To Have and to Hoax
Oct 20, 2026 · 1h 23m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 2016 disappearance of Sherry Papini in Redding, California, which initially appeared to be a kidnapping but was later revealed to be a staged hoax. The narrative covers the intense national search, the involvement of a private negotiator, and Sherry’s eventual "rescue" after 22 days, during which she claimed to have been tortured and branded.
Topics discussed
Sponsorship and introduction to the Sherry Papini case
The disappearance and initial police response
Keith and Sherry's relationship and community reaction
Keith's search efforts and media attention
Keith becomes a suspect and polygraph test
Investigation into Sherry's background and leads
The Tara Smith disappearance and Troy Zink
Sponsorship segments and critical first 72 hours
Cameron Gamble's ransom campaign and deadline
Sherry found alive on Thanksgiving morning
Hospital findings and public skepticism
Sherry's account of captivity and branding
Manhunt for suspects and community impact
DNA evidence and Sherry's inconsistent stories
Identifying James Reyes and the apartment match
James Reyes' confession and self-inflicted injuries
Confronting Sherry with the evidence
Sherry's guilty plea and Keith's divorce
Aftermath, restitution, and Hulu docuseries
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria