The After Show: The Suitcase Murders
Oct 19, 2026 · 33m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
FBI Special Agent Carrie Gibson joins the show to discuss the "Suitcase Murders," explaining how she helped identify victims Laura Simonson and Jenny Gamas and link them to former police officer Stephen Zelich. Gibson analyzes Zelich’s psychology, detailing how his obsession with BDSM and power control led him to murder the vulnerable women and hide their bodies for months. The episode also covers the investigative tactics used to disarm Zelich during his interview and offers red flags for women to recognize in online dating relationships.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Lincoln Tech career training
Introduction to FBI Agent Carrie Gibson
Background on the Suitcase Murders case
Agent Gibson's dual background in psychology and FBI
Investigation into Laura Simonson's disappearance
Discovery of bodies in suitcases on highway
Laura Simonson's life and vulnerabilities
Jenny Gamas's background and lack of missing report
Sponsor: Layla Sleep mattresses
Digital evidence and the 'Mr. Handcuffs' alias
Laura's psychological state and submission
Stephen Zelich's background as former police officer
Zelich's apartment conditions and psychological shift
Motel footage and the missing Laura
Police interview: Zelich's confession to killings
Interrogation tactics and profiling approach
Zelich's reaction to law enforcement interaction
Psychological analysis of victim vulnerability
Storage of bodies and motive of control
Preview of upcoming discussion on charges
Sponsor: Vinted app for selling clothes
First impressions of Stephen Zelich post-arrest
Zelich's admission and the role of breath play
Zelich's calm demeanor and hiding in plain sight
Psychological compulsion and lack of judgment
Red flags for women in online dating
Conclusion and retirement congratulations
Sponsor: Wise international money transfers
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria