Justice for Faith
Oct 31, 2026 · 1h 27m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode recounts the 14-year investigation into the 2012 murder of UNC student and Haliwa-Saponi tribal member Faith Hedgepeth. After years of cold-case frustration, investigators utilized advanced genetic genealogy to trace the killer's DNA to Guatemala, eventually identifying and arresting Miguel Salguero Olivares. The story highlights the community's grief, the role of new forensic technologies, and the final courtroom resolution that brought closure to Faith's family.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: LinkedIn for small business
Intro: Faith Hedgepeth's murder in Chapel Hill
Faith's life, community, and move to UNC
The night of the murder and discovery of body
Family reaction and crime scene details
Community vigil and initial suspect theories
Reconstructing the night: Thrill nightclub
Karina's early morning actions and calls
911 call and discovery of DNA evidence
Funeral, memorial, and early investigation dead ends
Investigating Jordan McCrary and Brandon Edwards
Investigating Eric Tekoi Jones and family frustration
Releasing the murder book to the public
The mysterious note: 'I'm not stupid, bitch'
Analyzing Karina's behavior and neighbor testimony
Sponsors: Audible and Lululemon
Interviewing Karina: Blood on her hand
Clearing Karina and the cold case status
Private investigator and DNA phenotyping sketch
Sponsors: LinkedIn and Lululemon
Update: New DNA technology and genealogy
Building family trees to find the suspect
Arrest of Miguel Salguero Olivares
Miguel's background and connection to the scene
Witness testimony on Miguel's behavior
Defense strategy: Blaming roommate Karina
Judge rules against third-party defense
Sponsor: Lululemon
Trial: Prosecution's DNA and fingerprint evidence
Trial: The note and handwriting analysis
Trial: Karina and Jordan's testimony
Closing arguments and jury deliberation
Verdict: Guilty of murder, rape, and burglary
Sentencing and family statements
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria