True Crime Vault: Do No Harm
Nov 3, 2026 · 1h 23m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the 1985 disappearance of Gail Katz, whose plastic surgeon husband Robert Berenbaum was suspected of strangling her and disposing of her body via his private plane. The narrative details the couple's abusive relationship, Berenbaum's subsequent reinvention as a successful surgeon in Las Vegas and North Dakota, and the relentless efforts of Gail's sister to keep the case alive. It concludes with Berenbaum's arrest and the revelation that he had indeed used his flying skills to cover up the crime.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Odoo business management software
Introduction: The perfect couple with a dark side
The Birnbaum family life on the Upper East Side
Gail's background and early relationship struggles
Robert's passion for flying and controlling behavior
Red flags: Violence against pets and family warnings
Marriage, move to 85th Street, and social isolation
Escalating abuse and the 1983 choking incident
The psychiatrist's warning letter and Gail's resolve
Sponsors: BetterHelp and OnDeck
The final argument and Gail's disappearance
Initial police investigation and Robert's lies
Robert's life in the Hamptons and false alibis
Discovery of flight records at Essex County Airport
The torso discovery and family's grief
Sponsor: Bombas socks
Robert's arrest and move to Las Vegas
Life in Las Vegas: New relationships and red flags
Move to North Dakota and the tiger incident
Cold case reopening and DNA evidence
Sponsors: Mint Mobile and The Mob
Trial begins: Prosecution's opening statement
Key evidence: Abuse history and flight demonstration
Defense case: Witness testimony and character attacks
Guilty verdict and sentencing to 20 years to life
Parole denial and Robert's confession
Legacy: Gail's House and final reflections
Outro: ABC News election coverage
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria