The After Show: Justice for Faith
Nov 2, 2026 · 35m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
Debra Roberts, Ryan Smith, and Pat LaLama discuss the 2020 episode "Justice for Faith," which covers the decade-long investigation into the 2012 murder of UNC student Faith Hedgepeth. The conversation details how genetic genealogy identified suspect Miguel Salguero Olivares and analyzes the recent trial, where the defense cast doubt on the DNA evidence and timeline. Despite the jury's guilty verdict, the hosts note that the lack of a clear motive leaves the family without a complete understanding of why the crime occurred.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Odoo business software
Introduction to the Faith Hedgepeth case
Background on Faith and the 2012 murder
Ryan Smith's decade-long investigation
Faith's character and family background
Reconstructing the night of the murder
Discovery of the body and initial police response
Challenges in the initial investigation
Questions surrounding roommate Karina Rosario
Preview: DNA and genetic genealogy
Sponsors: Proper Hills, Stamps.com
The mysterious note found at the scene
DNA evidence and the chaotic crime scene
Using genetic genealogy to identify the suspect
Miguel Olivares: The suspect's background
Charges and introduction of court reporter Pat LaLama
Sponsor: Whole Foods Market
Prosecution vs. Defense strategies in trial
The prosecution's theory of the crime
Emotional moment: Olivares' reaction to video call
The guilty verdict and courtroom reactions
Juror deliberations and struggles with motive
Family's reaction and lingering questions
Closing remarks and sponsors
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria