20/20 20/20

The Scream Murder, Episode 4: Scream Queens

Oct 28, 2026 · 30m

Summary

This episode of *The Scream Murder* details the 2006 murder of Cassie Jo Stoddard by 16-year-olds Brian Draper and Tori Atamchuk, exploring how their shared obsession with horror films and serial killers led to the crime. The hosts discuss the disturbing homemade video where the teens plan their murders, the discovery of a kill list, and the shock felt by the victims' families and friends who knew the boys as innocent. The narrative also highlights the confusion surrounding who was the primary instigator and the chilling aftermath, including a letter Brian sent to a potential victim from jail.

Topics discussed

Intro and the discovery of the homemade video The murder of Cassie and the rarity of teen killers How Brian and Tori met and their rapid bond Parental concerns over horror movie influence Fantasies of fame and comparisons to serial killers Tori's library monologue about their future movie Shannon Adamchek's shock at Tori's arrest The discovery of the kill list and supplies Danny's account of being stalked and targeted The plot to kill classmate Miranda Brian's manipulative letter to Danny from jail Amber's story of Tori's invitation to the party Matt sleeping over at Tori's house post-murder The planned horror movie starring Cassie Debate over who was the leader and follower Parents' reactions to the confession video Analysis of the killers' personalities and closing

More from 20/20

Murder on the Menu
Nov 21, 2026
True Crime Vault: Sealed with a Kill
Nov 17, 2026
The After Show: Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County Girls
Nov 16, 2026
Hiding Beneath the Surface: The Putnam County School Girls 
Nov 14, 2026
The Scream Murder, Episode 6: The Night Of
Nov 11, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria