The Scream Murder, Episode 2: Caught in a Lie
Oct 14, 2026 · 35m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
In this episode of *The Scream Murder*, Brian Draper confesses to participating in the murder of Cassie, revealing that he and Tori Adamcheck staged a scare that turned deadly. The narrative covers the discovery of buried evidence, including masks and knives, at Black Rock Canyon and the recovery of a shocking videotape. This footage captures the perpetrators' actions on the day of the crime, culminating in a chilling final scene that sets up the next installment.
Topics discussed
Intro and Wayfair ad
Episode recap: Cassie's murder and suspects
Brian Draper admits lying about movie alibi
New alibi: Breaking into cars and police skepticism
Police probe car burglary details; story falls apart
Detective Thomas confronts Brian; polygraph offered
Brian agrees to polygraph; discussion of its utility
Brian's mother Pam expresses worry and intuition
Background on Brian Draper and his family
Investigation at Pocatello High School; rumors about Matt
Brian returns for polygraph with parents present
Proper Hills digital frame ad
NoCD and Stamps.com ads
Brian confesses to returning to the house to scare victims
Details of the scare plan: lights, masks, and knives
The attack: Tori stabs Cassie; Brian's reaction
Carvana and SimpliSafe ads
Family's reaction to confession; 'incredible boy' comment
Brian talks to camera as if Cassie is alive
Recovering evidence: masks and knives at Black Rock Canyon
Discovery of hidden videotape; viewing the footage
Cliffhanger: Tape contents and Shopify ad
More from 20/20
Listen ad-free on Castria