The Creep Off

Hosts Vinnie and Carl discuss their disastrous Miami Dolphins season before tackling the "Creepiest Grandparent" competition.

Hosts Carl, Vinny, and guest Brian McBride discuss the death of wrestler Andy Williams and a controversial arrest in Egypt involving a TV host.

Hosts Vinny and Carl discuss Jerry Banfield’s recent controversies and a local comedian’s arrest for CP possession.

Hosts Vinny and Carl discuss technical glitches and audience-suggested consequences before detailing the crimes of the Red Light Orderlies, Kazakhstani men who murdered and cannibalized women.

Hosts Vinny and Carl compete in the "Creepiest OnlyFans Model" category, with Vinny presenting Nicolette Keogh, who damaged Airbnbs by urinating on furniture.

Hosts Carl and Vinny compete to present the creepiest mechanic, with Carl detailing the abduction and murder of an 11-year-old girl by Joseph Smith,…

Hosts Vinny and Carl review last week’s winner, the "Paper Bag Rapist," before competing in this week’s BC Day-themed episode.

Hosts Vinny and Carl discuss two Spanish serial killers: Alfredo Galan, the "Playing Card Killer," and Jose Antonio Rodriguez Vega, who murdered elderly women.

Hosts Vinny and Carl, joined by guest Brian Johnson and results girl Danny, discuss Vinny’s upcoming appearance on Chad Zumach’s show and announce the winner of their Pride Month contest.