The Creep Off The Creep Off

Episode 326: The Pig That Ate St. Louis

Aug 17, 2026 · 1h 22m

Summary

Hosts Vinny and Carl compete in the "Creepiest OnlyFans Model" category, with Vinny presenting Nicolette Keogh, who damaged Airbnbs by urinating on furniture. Carl counters with Sierra Jane Insko, a scammer who stole vehicles and confessed to murdering a fan. Guest Mahalia announces Carl’s victory and discusses humorous "Wheel of Consequences" ideas, including a slideshow of fan-submitted feet pictures.

Topics discussed

Intro and disclaimer Movie references and hero cop analogy Behind the scenes: email and tech issues Audio check and banter with Vinny Feet day and Mahalia's inbox Other submissions and coffee rant Vito show announcement and Super Chat intro Vinny's emceeing story and stadium talk Super Chats and drop-shipped coffee Competition: Creepiest OnlyFans model intro Kyo and the peeing on things debate Nicolette Keogh: Airbnb urination charges OnlyFans CEO and the scammer's bio Sierra's truck theft and lies about being a nurse Sierra's arrest and prison sentence Super Chats and Cop Cam intro Cop Cam: Felony warrant and resisting arrest Cop Cam: Mom arrives and domestic violence history Scum Parade: Mick Jagger and Rod Stewart rumors Naked woman driving without consent Man moves dead girlfriend's body in car Teen kills family and uses ChatGPT Dan Shrack and To Catch a Predator connection Mark Kelly: Daycare abuse conviction Housing market and mouse extermination story Rapid fire and final super chat Outro and next episode tease
Listen ad-free on Castria