My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

556 - The Halloween Special

Oct 29, 2026 · 1h 9m

Summary

In this Halloween episode, Karen and Georgia explore the Salem witch trials, detailing the 1692 hysteria that resulted in the execution of 26 people. They discuss the historical context of Puritan anxiety, the initial accusations against vulnerable women, and the eventual exoneration of the accused. The hosts also address the debunked ergot poisoning theory and reflect on the lasting legacy of the trials in modern Salem.

Topics discussed

Cold open: Staged truck accidents in New Orleans Sponsor: United Healthcare Halloween intro, candy tasting, and Spirit Halloween pin Fan call promo and spooky season merch Animated segment: The Were Pig Sponsor: Shopify Salem Witch Trials: Historical context and Puritan society The Paris family, witch cakes, and initial accusations Arrests, confessions, and the spread of accusations The trials begin: Bridget Bishop and spectral evidence Sponsor: Simply Safe home security Sponsor: Stitch Fix Giles Corey's death and the end of the trials Listener mail: Debunking the ergot poisoning theory Alternative theories: Abuse, hysteria, and land disputes Sponsor: Simply Safe (reprise) and community control Sponsors: Simply Safe and Hatch Sleep Clock The Bell Witch: Origins and initial strange encounters Escalating hauntings and the Bell family's isolation Community involvement and the arrival of Andrew Jackson Jackson's visit and the entity's interference with Betsy John Bell's death and the entity's final departure Theories on the Bell Witch: Kate Batts and the Red Book Modern legends and the conclusion of the episode Outro, socials, and sponsors: Dr. Teal's and Cheap Caribbean

More from My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

MFM Presents… Heart
Nov 20, 2026
559 - We Simply Can’t
Nov 19, 2026
Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 125: Bedside Astrologer!
Nov 18, 2026
MFM Minisode 514
Nov 16, 2026
558 - Eat the Wrapper
Nov 12, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria