558 - Eat the Wrapper
Nov 12, 2026 · 1h 2m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
The hosts discuss their Halloween makeup experiments and a recent Dixie Chicks concert, reflecting on the band's past censorship. They then present a true crime story about the 1987 murder of Sherry Orofino, focusing on the investigation into a corrupt police officer. The episode concludes with a historical account of the 1928 Transcontinental Foot Race, detailing the grueling conditions and financial mismanagement of the event.
Topics discussed
Audible sponsorship and intro
Halloween makeup and eyeshadow trends
David Bowie in The Labyrinth and movie memories
Dolly Parton concert and political commentary
Podcast recommendation: Cold Season 5
Network highlights, merch, and Signal Awards
Setting the scene: Millbrook, NY, 1987
Sherry Orofino's disappearance
Car found and witness accounts
Vented and Dr. Teal's sponsorships
Body discovery and homicide confirmation
Suspect Officer Ronald Langer identified
Jennifer Hummel's testimony and assault
Langer's investigation and resignation
Langer's federal charges and defense
Impact on family and systemic issues
Vinted and Dr. Teal's sponsorships
Hungry Root sponsorship
Route 66 100th anniversary introduction
1927 Wrigley Ocean Marathon context
Introduction of C.C. Pyle
Announcement of the transcontinental foot race
Race conditions and medical warnings
Pyle's circus and monetization plan
Runners and race start in Los Angeles
Pyle's luxury RV and runner accommodations
Early race challenges and dropouts
Financial struggles and spending cuts
Physical toll and route progress
Andy Payne's tonsillitis and hygiene issues
Car accidents and dehydration
Racism and hostile encounters
Mid-race status and Pyle's money troubles
Town resistance and Pyle fleeing
Final states and physical breakdown
Arrival in New York
Madison Square Garden finale
Low attendance and race conclusion
Andy Payne's victory and legacy
Post-race physical effects
Pyle's bankruptcy and unpaid prizes
Historical context of endurance events
Celebrating Route 66 and Pyle's spectacle
Credits and production team
Virgin Voyage and Bank of America sponsors
Clinique Moisture Surge sponsorship
More from My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Listen ad-free on Castria