My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

MFM Presents… Heart

Nov 20, 2026 · 31m

Summary

This episode of *My Favorite Murder* features the first installment of the Apple Original podcast *Heart*, which investigates the suspicious deaths of two men who shared the same transplanted heart. The story follows Sonny Graham, who received a heart from Terry Cottle and subsequently fell in love with Terry’s widow, Cheryl, before both men died by self-inflicted gunshot wounds. The narrative explores the mystery surrounding these deaths, the theory of organ memory, and the skepticism of family members who believe the official suicide verdicts are incorrect.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: Guardian Bikes, Bank of America, We Feed Raw Introduction to the podcast 'Heart' and content warning Opening meditation on the nature of the heart Sonny Graham's death and the arrival of family The connection to donor Terry Cottle and their shared fate Sonny Graham's reputation as 'The Lion' on Hilton Head Sonny's early life, marriage to Elaine, and career Sonny's legacy and the onset of heart failure The heart transplant from Terry Cottle Sonny's recovery and perceived change in personality Sponsors: Guardian Bikes, Bank of America, We Feed Raw Sonny's decision to contact the donor's family Meeting Cheryl Cottle and the initial connection Sonny's infatuation with Cheryl and friends' disbelief Divorce from Elaine and marriage to Cheryl Theories on heart memory and cellular intelligence Sponsors: Guardian Bikes, Bank of America, We Feed Raw News of Sonny's death reaches friends and family The scene of the crime and initial investigation Family skepticism and the GBI investigation Case closure and final thoughts on the mystery Credits and production team acknowledgment Sponsors: Guardian Bikes and Microsoft AI Innovators Hub Sponsor: Dr. Thiel's Magnesium Spray

More from My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

559 - We Simply Can’t
Nov 19, 2026
Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 125: Bedside Astrologer!
Nov 18, 2026
MFM Minisode 514
Nov 16, 2026
558 - Eat the Wrapper
Nov 12, 2026
Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 124: Errant Duct Tape
Nov 11, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria