My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

545 - Don’t You Like Weirdos?

Aug 13, 2026 · 1h 0m

Summary

Karen and Georgia discuss their outfits before covering the true story of Candy, who fought for justice after being raped by Dr. John Schneeberger, who evaded DNA tests by implanting stolen blood in his arm. Georgia then recounts the 1814 Napoleonic Hoax, where a man tricked the London stock market by falsely claiming Napoleon was dead. The episode also features network highlights from Bananas, Brief Recess, Disgraceland, and I Said No Gifts.

Topics discussed

Ads for MG Symptom Impact, Lego Duplo, and Vital Proteins Hosts discuss Georgia's jumpsuit and past fashion regrets Corrections corner and highlights from other Exactly Right podcasts Introduction to the Forensic Files case of Candy and Dr. Schneeberger Candy's assault, the suspicious drug, and her decision to get a rape kit The town's disbelief and the first failed DNA tests Private investigator finds matching DNA on a chapstick The suspicious blood draw and the discovery of the implanted vein The stepdaughter's discovery, arrest, and Dr. Schneeberger's conviction Candy's film project and the hosts' reaction to the case Introduction to the 1814 'Napoleon is Dead' financial hoax The spread of the rumor and the resulting stock market crash Investigation reveals the hoaxers and their massive profits The trial, punishment, and historical context of the hoax Honking Hoorays: Listener stories about debt and vacations Outro, credits, and ads for Virgin Voyages and Ridwell
Listen ad-free on Castria