My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

544 - Everything Is Worth It

Aug 6, 2026 · 1h 20m

Summary

Karen and Georgia discuss their recent trip to Dollywood and Georgia’s sobriety before diving into two true crime stories. They cover the 1964 kidnapping of baby Paul Fronzak from a Chicago hospital and his eventual identification decades later. The hosts then detail the 1990 "Wedding Sting," where undercover cops Lacey "Moon" Brown and Debbie Williams faked a wedding to bust a drug ring in Michigan.

Topics discussed

Ads for The Shards, Audible, and SimpliSafe Netflix fame, outfit charts, and a trip to Dollywood Book recommendations and Proclensity merch The 1964 kidnapping of baby Paul Fronzak Paul's discovery, DNA tests, and the real Kevin Fronzak The War on Drugs and the rise of crack cocaine in Michigan Officer Moon's troubled past and redemption Planning the fake wedding sting operation The wedding sting execution and its aftermath Closing ads for SimpliSafe and vacation planning
Listen ad-free on Castria