Murder: True Crime Stories Murder: True Crime Stories

MYSTERY: The Dexter Killer of Edmonton

Oct 30, 2026 · 44m

Summary

This episode details the 2008 murder of Johnny Altinger by Mark Twitchell, an aspiring filmmaker who lured his victim to a rented garage in Edmonton, Alberta, using a fake online dating profile. Host Carter Roy explores how Twitchell’s obsession with the TV show *Dexter* and his prior attack on another victim led to his conviction for first-degree murder. The narrative traces the investigation, the discovery of a deleted "confession" document, and Twitchell’s four shifting explanations for the crime, culminating in his recent parole denial.

Topics discussed

Black Friday Crime House Plus promotion Introduction: The Dexter Killer and movie blood Show intro and Murder Mystery Fridays format Case overview: October 2008 timeline Setting the scene: Edmonton in October 2008 Victim profile: Johnny Altinger's life The date: Meeting 'Jen' on Plenty of Fish The garage encounter and Johnny's last email Disappearance and the suspicious Costa Rica email Police investigation and Mark Twitchell's alibi Interrogation and the $40 car story Twitchell's background and the 'House of Cards' film Forensic evidence: Luminol and the SK Confessions document Surveillance and Halloween arrest via fake investor The second victim: Gilles Thoreau's escape Confession and recovery of Johnny's remains Trial: The MAPLE defense and Dexter Facebook evidence Verdict, sentencing, and early post-trial events 2026 Parole hearing and Version 4 confession Host analysis: Dexter influence and the nature of the lie Outro and Crime House Plus subscription details

More from Murder: True Crime Stories

Thanksgiving EXTRA: The UnBelievable - Sweet Revenge
Nov 21, 2026
MYSTERY: Mike Lynch & the Sinking of Bayesian
Nov 20, 2026
UNSOLVED: Ronda Reynolds Pt. 2
Nov 19, 2026
UNSOLVED: Ronda Reynolds Pt. 1
Nov 17, 2026
MYSTERY: The Disappearance of Maura Murray
Nov 13, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria