Murder: True Crime Stories Murder: True Crime Stories

MYSTERY: The Disappearance of Maura Murray

Nov 13, 2026 · 54m

Summary

This episode investigates the 2004 disappearance of Maura Murray, a UMass nursing student who vanished after crashing her car in New Hampshire. It details her life, struggles with mental health, and the subsequent investigation, highlighting the family's decades-long fight for answers and transparency. The narrative covers unresolved leads, including a recent fingerprint match to a convicted felon, and concludes with the host's personal reflections on the case.

Topics discussed

Black Friday Crime House Plus promotion The night of Maura Murray's crash Reflections on life stories and endings Show introduction and episode overview Maura's disappearance and online rumors Sponsor: Quince wardrobe essentials Family summers in the White Mountains Maura's childhood in Hanson, Massachusetts Father's influence and family dynamics High school athletic and academic success Attending West Point like her sister Struggles with eating disorders at West Point Incident at Fort Knox and cry for help Relationship with Bill and post-9/11 fears Julie's life after West Point and injury Maura's suspended license in New Hampshire Christmas 2003 and gifts from Bill Return to school and the Saturn car Kathleen's relapse and Maura's distress Maura's isolation and lack of roommate The night of the accident: drinking and driving Aftermath of the crash and father's reaction Sponsor: Quince premium foundations Promo: Nisi Nash's new Crime House show Sponsor: SimpliSafe home security Maura's final preparations and searches Last recorded activities and ATM withdrawal Witnesses at the crash site in Haverville School bus driver Butch Atwood's account Conflicting details of the initial response Police arrival and initial scene investigation Evidence found in the crashed Saturn Search efforts and lack of eastward search Fred's reaction and arrival in Haverville Tracking dog search and vehicle theory Fred's recognition of the tailpipe rag FBI refusal and police press release Suicide theory and the book in the car Unidentified phone call from Londonderry Online tips and mixed-up dates Bill's phone records and later legal issues Rumors about Loon Mountain workers Local leads and police inaction Sponsor: Quince organic cotton hoodie Sponsor: SimpliSafe AI security system The rusty knife tip from a local man Blood evidence found in a closet State downplaying of blood test results The Murray Exemption and cold case unit Fred's continued searches and seatbelt finding Cadaver dogs alert at the A-frame house Family's rushed visit and forensic oversight Failure to dig under the tank and disappointment Loss of the blue ribbon tree and marker Death of sister Kathleen and FBI database entry Julie's TikTok campaign for awareness Family protests at the state office Private investigator Lou Berry's theories Fingerprint match to Stephen Baldwin Baldwin's arrest and criminal history Baldwin's West Point connection and name change Baldwin's denial and FBI interview No charges and new cold case investigators Failed cold case commission bill Host's personal connection and mental health Host's theory: mental health and accident Host's theory: planning to return Host's theory: stopped by a man Host's theory: evidence of abduction Host's conclusion: taken and never found Critique of state police transparency Call to action and Crime House Plus promo Credits and production team

More from Murder: True Crime Stories

Thanksgiving EXTRA: The UnBelievable - Sweet Revenge
Nov 21, 2026
MYSTERY: Mike Lynch & the Sinking of Bayesian
Nov 20, 2026
UNSOLVED: Ronda Reynolds Pt. 2
Nov 19, 2026
UNSOLVED: Ronda Reynolds Pt. 1
Nov 17, 2026
SOLVED: Jennifer & Abby Blagg Pt. 2
Nov 12, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria