UNSOLVED: Ronda Reynolds Pt. 2
Nov 19, 2026 · 47m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 13-year fight by Barb Thompson to prove her daughter Rhonda Reynolds was murdered rather than committing suicide. Host Carter Roy covers the flawed initial investigation, the legal battles against the coroner, and the eventual 2011 inquest where a jury ruled the death a homicide. Although the inquest named Ron and Jonathan Reynolds as responsible, no criminal charges were ever filed, leaving the case officially unsolved.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Crime House Plus Black Friday Offer
Introduction: The 13-Year Fight for Rhonda Reynolds
Sponsors: Talkiatry and Weight Loss by HERS
The Funeral and Early Suspicion of Ron Reynolds
Investigation Flaws: The Gun, Fingerprints, and Pressure
Detective Berry's Disagreement and Internal Conflict
Expert Review: 'Major Police Malfeasance' and Retaliation
Interrogating Ron Reynolds: Inconsistencies and Lies
File Analysis: Staged Scene and Destroyed Evidence
State Review Concludes Suicide Despite Doubts
Sponsor: Weight Loss by HERS
Sponsors: Fact Up and Hard Rock Bet Casino
Forensic Challenges: Ballistics and Blanket Evidence
New Leads: Katie Hutula's Message and Ally Larry
Coroner Wilson's Refusal to Reopen the Case
The 2009 Civil Hearing and Jury Verdict
Court Order and Wilson's Refusal to Change Certificate
Sponsors: Weight Loss by HERS and Hard Rock Bet
Sponsor: Hard Rock Bet Casino
Certificate Changed to Undetermined in 2011
The 2011 Inquest: Opening and Early Testimony
Inquest Testimony: DNA, Mirror Message, and Katie
Inquest Verdict: Homicide Found by Jury
Warrants Issued and Barb's Closure
Legal Aftermath: Appeals and Family Press Conference
Conclusion: No Charges and Rhonda's Legacy
Outro and Credits
Sponsor: Primally Pure Skincare
More from Murder: True Crime Stories
Listen ad-free on Castria