MYSTERY: Serial Killer Grandparents
Summary
This episode details the Copeland Farm Murders, where elderly farmer Ray Copeland lured vulnerable drifters to his Missouri farm in the 1980s under the guise of employment. He murdered five men to cover up a cattle fraud scheme, burying their bodies on the property. The case unraveled when one victim escaped and alerted authorities, leading to the discovery of the bodies and the arrest of Ray and his wife, Fay. While Ray was convicted, Fay’s guilt remains debated; she was sentenced to death for five murders, with evidence suggesting she may have been an accomplice or an abused victim.
Topics discussed
Intro: The First 48 promo and Copeland Farm teaser
Show intro: Murder Mystery Fridays and case overview
Sponsors: Weight loss pill and Wayfair back-to-school
The Scheme: Ray Copeland's cattle check fraud
The Murders: Five men killed to hide the scam
Sponsors: Boll & Branch bedding and The First 48
Sponsor: Primally Pure makeup
The Whistleblower: Jack McCormick escapes and reports Ray
The Discovery: Police find bodies buried on the farm
The Evidence: Faye's list and the quilt of victims' clothes
Sponsors: Alma therapy and Indeed jobs
The Trials: Convictions and death sentences for Ray and Faye
Aftermath: Ray's death and Faye's medical parole
Unresolved Questions: The missing men and Faye's guilt
Outro: Credits, Crime House Plus, and Mercury banking
Listen ad-free on Castria