SOLVED: The Colonial Parkway Murders 2
Summary
Host Carter Roy details the decades-long investigation into the Colonial Parkway murders, where four couples were killed between 1986 and 1989. After years of false leads and family activism, modern genetic genealogy identified deceased suspect Alan Wilmer Sr. as the killer of several victims. The episode explores the complex closure for families who finally know who killed their loved ones, but never why, as Wilmer died before facing trial.
Topics discussed
Intro: Crimes of Reddit and the nature of cold case closure
Crime House Plus subscription offer
Overview of the Colonial Parkway murders victims
Ad: Weight Loss by HERS
Early investigation struggles and jurisdictional splits
The Shenandoah murders and the Daryl Rice false lead
Bill Thomas takes action and meets Fred Atwell
Ad: BetMGM Sportsbook
Fred Atwell's fraud and the suicide hotline suspect
Private investigator Spengola's controversial theories
Genealogical DNA breakthrough and Bill's pressure tactics
Ad: Bowl and Branch sheets
Ad: Earnest loans and What Happened to the Mixed Days
Identifying Alan Wilmer through DNA matches
Confirming Wilmer as the Colonial Parkway killer
Unresolved cases and the limitations of posthumous justice
Outro, credits, and Indeed ad
Listen ad-free on Castria