Murder: True Crime Stories Murder: True Crime Stories

UNSOLVED: Cindy James, Pt. 1

Nov 3, 2026 · 54m

Summary

Host Carter Roy introduces the case of Cindy James, a Vancouver nurse who endured seven years of stalking, harassment, and violent attacks. The episode details her troubled past, her marriage to Roy Makepeace, and the conflicting police investigations that questioned her credibility. It concludes with her disappearance in May 1989, setting the stage for the subsequent inquest that debated whether she was a victim of crime or acting out her own delusions.

Topics discussed

Black Friday promotion for Crime House Plus Introduction to Cindy James and her police reports Show intro and content warnings Cindy's disappearance and the upcoming search Cindy's career as a school director and childhood Family dynamics and moving to Vancouver Affair with Roy Makepeace and marriage issues Divorce and first police call in October 1982 Police investigation and Officer McBride moves in Harassment continues and Roy's surveillance Threatening letters and the January 1983 assault Victim compensation and doubts about Cindy's story Cindy identifies Roy and returns to shared home Hiring private investigator Caban and escalating threats The knife attack and police belief in Cindy Confronting Roy and the family's reaction Cindy's disappearance in July 1984 and discovery Hypnosis, suicide attempt, and self-dialed calls False fire report and hypothermia incident Basement fire, psychiatric care, and name change New threats in Richmond and the 1988 attack Police skepticism and Cindy's plan for self-defense May 1989 disappearance and final clues Outro and Crime House Plus promotion

More from Murder: True Crime Stories

Thanksgiving EXTRA: The UnBelievable - Sweet Revenge
Nov 21, 2026
MYSTERY: Mike Lynch & the Sinking of Bayesian
Nov 20, 2026
UNSOLVED: Ronda Reynolds Pt. 2
Nov 19, 2026
UNSOLVED: Ronda Reynolds Pt. 1
Nov 17, 2026
MYSTERY: The Disappearance of Maura Murray
Nov 13, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria