UNSOLVED: Cindy James, Pt. 1
Nov 3, 2026 · 54m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
Host Carter Roy introduces the case of Cindy James, a Vancouver nurse who endured seven years of stalking, harassment, and violent attacks. The episode details her troubled past, her marriage to Roy Makepeace, and the conflicting police investigations that questioned her credibility. It concludes with her disappearance in May 1989, setting the stage for the subsequent inquest that debated whether she was a victim of crime or acting out her own delusions.
Topics discussed
Black Friday promotion for Crime House Plus
Introduction to Cindy James and her police reports
Show intro and content warnings
Cindy's disappearance and the upcoming search
Cindy's career as a school director and childhood
Family dynamics and moving to Vancouver
Affair with Roy Makepeace and marriage issues
Divorce and first police call in October 1982
Police investigation and Officer McBride moves in
Harassment continues and Roy's surveillance
Threatening letters and the January 1983 assault
Victim compensation and doubts about Cindy's story
Cindy identifies Roy and returns to shared home
Hiring private investigator Caban and escalating threats
The knife attack and police belief in Cindy
Confronting Roy and the family's reaction
Cindy's disappearance in July 1984 and discovery
Hypnosis, suicide attempt, and self-dialed calls
False fire report and hypothermia incident
Basement fire, psychiatric care, and name change
New threats in Richmond and the 1988 attack
Police skepticism and Cindy's plan for self-defense
May 1989 disappearance and final clues
Outro and Crime House Plus promotion
More from Murder: True Crime Stories
Listen ad-free on Castria