UNSOLVED: Cindy James, Pt. 2
Nov 5, 2026 · 47m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode investigates the 1989 disappearance of Cindy James in British Columbia, detailing the extensive search and the discovery of her body two weeks later. It covers the controversial inquest, which featured over 80 witnesses and resulted in an "undetermined" verdict due to conflicting evidence regarding suicide versus homicide. The narrative explores the legal and social failures that left James unsupported during seven years of alleged stalking, highlighting the enduring mystery of her death.
Topics discussed
Black Friday Crime House Plus Promo
Introduction: The Disappearance of Cindy James
Show Intro and Community Thanks
Episode Recap: Seven Years of Threats
Discovery of the Locked Car in Safeway Lot
Forensic Evidence and Initial Search Efforts
Interrogation of Ex-Husband Roy Makepeace
Family Media Campaign and Police Inaction
Discovery of Body Behind Abandoned House
Forensic Analysis of Ligatures and Needle Marks
Toxicology Results: Drugs and Morphine
Knot Specialist Analysis of Self-Binding
Psychiatric History and Disposal of Evidence
Police Conclusion vs. Family's Homicide Theory
Overview of the Coroner's Inquest Process
Inquest Testimony: Evidence and Witnesses
Forensic Psychiatrist's Assessment of Cindy
Jury Verdict: Undetermined and Family Reaction
Legacy: Roy Makepeace and Systemic Failures
Closing Reflections and Outro
More from Murder: True Crime Stories
Listen ad-free on Castria