Morbid Morbid

The Murders of Mary Phagan and Leo Frank

Sep 17, 2026 · 1h 16m

Summary

Hosts Ash and Elena discuss the 1913 murder of Mary Fagan, a 13-year-old factory worker found dead in Atlanta. The episode details the flawed investigation that initially targeted Newt Lee, a Black night watchman, before shifting suspicion to Leo Frank, the factory owner. The hosts critique the police's reliance on racial prejudice and circumstantial evidence, highlighting how the case became a sensationalized media event. They also cover the discovery of a bloody shirt and the involvement of Pinkerton agent Harry Scott, who further compromised Frank's defense.

Topics discussed

Movie trailers for Verity and Carrie Discussion on the film adaptation of Carrie Spooky season plans and Halloween listener theme Choosing Kif characters and special edition request Introduction to Mary Fagan's background Mary's life as a factory worker in Atlanta Working conditions and health issues in 1913 Mary's final day and pay collection Discovery of Mary's body by Newt Lee Description of Mary's injuries and the basement Investigation challenges in the dark basement Analysis of the first note found near the body Analysis of the second note and suspect theories Debate on Newt Lee's potential involvement Newt Lee's account of finding the body Racial bias in the initial investigation Handwriting analysis and Newt's detention Interrogation of factory owner Leo Frank Leo Frank's demeanor and alibi details Leo Frank's identification of Mary at the morgue Timeline discrepancies and suspicion of Frank Sponsor segment for Quince clothing Sponsor segment for Earnin app Sponsor segment for insurance plans Press reaction to Leo Frank's arrest Newt Lee's cooperation with police Leo Frank's detailed alibi statement Forensic analysis of Mary's injuries Press theories on the motive for the murder Hiring of Pinkerton detective Harry Scott Frank's omission of a witness to police Discovery of the bloody shirt in Newt's apartment Formal arrest of Newt Lee and Leo Frank Discussion on the term 'frolic' in testimony Witness testimony contradicting Frank's guilt Contradictory accounts of Frank's behavior Re-evaluation of the notes as evidence James Conley's affidavit and testimony Prosecution's handling of Conley's affidavit Conley's illiteracy and recognition of notes Press accusations of police manipulation Conley's second, detailed statement Newt Lee's testimony at the trial Defense witnesses and trial replay Influence of sensational press on the trial Sponsor segment for health and wellness Sponsor segment for movie trailer Closing arguments and verdict of guilty Sentencing and Leo Frank's final statement Judge's doubts and motion for new trial Evidence of bias in the original trial Debate on Conley's role and punishment Post-sentencing evidence pointing away from Frank Public unrest and failed jailbreak attempt The lynching of Leo Frank Statement by the lynching mob Reflection on modern desensitization to violence Burial and public reaction to the lynching Alonzo Mann's confession 70 years later State pardon and end of the case Reflection on the lack of justice Fun fact about koala fingerprints Movie trailer for The Love Hypothesis

More from Morbid

Bernhard Goetz: The Subway Vigilante
Nov 19, 2026
Getting Eerie & Existential with Ethan Hawke
Nov 16, 2026
The Ghosts of Summerwind
Nov 12, 2026
Colton Harris-Moore: The Barefoot Bandit (AKA AyleSteelya Earhart)
Nov 9, 2026
Harold Shipman (Part 2)
Nov 5, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria