Bernhard Goetz: The Subway Vigilante
Nov 19, 2026 · 43m
More True Crime podcasts · More Comedy podcasts
Summary
Hosts Ash and Elena begin by sharing a humorous anecdote about Ash stepping in a pile of manure after meeting Ethan Hawke. The episode then shifts to a true crime story about Bernard Goetz, the "subway vigilante" who shot four teenagers in 1984. The hosts explore Goetz's traumatic background, the public's polarized reaction to his actions, and the controversial trial that resulted in his acquittal on most charges.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: State Farm and Disney Bundle
Intro: Ethan Hawke interview and stepping in dog poop
Bernie Goetz: Early life and family scandal
Bernie Goetz: Marriage, career, and return to NYC
Sponsors: State Farm, Disney, and YouTube Premium
Bernie Goetz: Assaults and purchase of a revolver
The Subway Shooting: Events and immediate aftermath
Public reaction and Bernie Goetz's arrest
Sponsors: SimpliSafe and Disney Bundle
Debate: Vigilante justice vs. racial bias and victimhood
The Trial: Verdict, sentencing, and civil lawsuits
Outro: Bernie's later life and jellyfish trivia
Sponsors: Angie and Ashley Luxe
More from Morbid
Listen ad-free on Castria