Morbid Morbid

Colton Harris-Moore: The Barefoot Bandit (AKA AyleSteelya Earhart)

Nov 9, 2026 · 1h 4m

Summary

This episode of Morbid details the story of Colton Harris Moore, known as the Barefoot Bandit, who evaded law enforcement for years while committing numerous burglaries and thefts on Bainbridge Island. Hosts Ash and Elena explore his traumatic childhood, marked by neglect and abuse, which led to his life in the wilderness and escalating criminal activities. The narrative covers his multiple escapes from juvenile facilities and the community's complex mix of fear and sympathy as he terrorized local residents.

Topics discussed

Intro: Terry Cottle and Sonny Graham story Sponsor: Lowe's Black Friday deals Host banter and episode preview Introduction to Colton Harris Moore Colton's abusive childhood and neglect CPS failures and early behavioral issues Juvenile theft and running away to the woods Escalating thefts and juvenile detention Living off the grid and police surveillance Credit card theft and online orders Debate on Colton's weapon and survival Mother's denial and harboring the fugitive Police discovery of pizza boxes and campsites The pizza delivery sting and arrest Release and new felony charges Mother's role and legal considerations Sponsors: GoodRx, Realize, Carvana Second capture and juvenile detention Community reaction and sympathy debate Psychiatric evaluation and 'war on police' Recruiting Harley Davidson for crimes Harley's background and Colton's aging Sentencing to Green Hill School Life in juvenile detention and escape Public anxiety and sheriff's statement Theft of fire station equipment Car chase and surrender at grocery store Local sympathy vs. escalating danger Mother's comments on summer weather Flashback to previous year's chase Armed threats and Chamber of Commerce Banter about ugly islands and ATMs Grocery store ransacking and evidence Security footage and blood evidence Shift from survival to thrill-seeking Analysis of Colton's motivation Transition to sponsor segment Sponsor: Chime banking Sponsor: Spectrum internet Theft of Bob Rivers' airplane Colton's first plane flight Bob Rivers' reaction to the flight Surviving plane crashes and anger Learning to fly from manuals Hubris and escalating vehicle thefts Crashing five planes total National fame and media interest T-shirts and public infatuation Mother's exploitation of fame Local annoyance with media attention Dateline and 48 Hours coverage Naming the 'Barefoot Bandit' Banter on episode title ideas Boat theft and leaving the island Colton's physical growth and risk Impact on island tourism and housing Bounty hunter and detective collaboration DNA match from crashed plane Text message to Bahamian resort Chase and boat theft in Bahamas Surrender and deportation to Miami Reflection on lack of home Plea deal and profit restrictions Counting the victims and planes Sentencing and lawyer's quote Colton's post-release statements Banter on news coverage and tin cans History of the can opener Dancing with the Stars voting Closing and voting instructions Sponsor: Realize by Taboola Sponsor terms and conditions Sponsor: Old Spice holiday packs

More from Morbid

Bernhard Goetz: The Subway Vigilante
Nov 19, 2026
Getting Eerie & Existential with Ethan Hawke
Nov 16, 2026
The Ghosts of Summerwind
Nov 12, 2026
Harold Shipman (Part 2)
Nov 5, 2026
Harold Shipman (Part 1)
Nov 2, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria