The Exorcism of Anneliese Michel (Part 2)
Sep 24, 2026 · 51m
More True Crime podcasts · More Comedy podcasts
Summary
This episode details the tragic 1975 case of Anneliese Michel, whose severe depression was misdiagnosed as demonic possession by Catholic priests. The hosts discuss how Father Alt and Father Renz subjected her to 67 grueling exorcism rites over nine months, ignoring her deteriorating health and starvation. Despite medical warnings, the priests continued the rituals until she died, leading to their conviction for manslaughter through criminal neglect. The story highlights the dangers of religious delusion and the failure of the church and family to seek proper psychiatric care.
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Southern New Hampshire University
Sponsor: Pantene Miracle Rescue Hair Care
Pod Lab cleanup and ice machine discovery
Recap: Doctor visits and the trial setup
Father Alt's involvement and psychiatric history
Diagnosis: Pseudohallucinations vs Psychosis
Father Alt experiences the smells on a walk
Anneliese's decline and roommate Ursula's account
Relationship with Peter and emotional numbness
Stigma of mental illness in the family
Failed treatments and family dynamics
Weekend visits home and erratic symptoms
Physical injuries and animal-like behavior
Mother's past overprotection and resentment
Doctor Leoner and the grimacing face hallucinations
Priests' interest and advice for strict religious life
Sponsor: SimplySafe Home Monitoring
Sponsor: The Love Hypothesis on Prime Video
Anneliese's letter to Father Alt in September
Conflict between medical and spiritual narratives
Thea Hein's account and the push for exorcism
Doctors' consensus: Epilepsy and depression
Social isolation and segregation from friends
Aversion to religious icons and prayer
Inability to enter church and worsening behavior
Witnessing the grimacing face and stiffening
Debate on medical help vs exorcism
Father Alt's conviction after a screaming episode
First small exorcism at the family home
Building the case for the Bishop and worsening symptoms
Identification of Judas Iscariot as the demon
Discussion on the Judas Kiss imagery
Interpretation of the demon's hidden agenda
Recruiting Father Arnold Renns for approval
Recording mishap and date confusion
Sponsor: GoodRx Companion
Sponsor: SoFi Financial App
Sponsor: Carrie on Prime Video
Relevance of Carrie's themes to modern bullying
The 67 Rites of Exorcism and physical exertion
Audio recordings of the exorcism sessions
The six demons and their identities
Priests' belief that demons cannot kill
Neglect of basic physical needs during rituals
Doctor Roth's visit and lack of medical intervention
Final visit by Father Alt and Anneliese's condition
Physical injuries: chipped teeth and bite marks
Final exorcism session and absolution
Anneliese's death and shock to the community
State investigation and autopsy findings
Priests' defense of anti-religious bias
Shared religious psychosis and legal challenges
Exhumation and the nun's vision
Court verdict: Manslaughter for all four defendants
Church policy changes regarding exorcism
Interview with Thea Hein decades later
Reflection on religious psychosis and medical neglect
The tragedy of Anneliese's potential
Anneliese's struggle for help until the end
Sponsor: State Farm and 'Mind Your Business' coin
Outro and final sponsor mention
Sponsor: Ozempic
More from Morbid
Listen ad-free on Castria