The Eddy Brothers and the High Life Ski Club
Summary
This Morbid episode explores the history of the Eddy Brothers, 19th-century mediums in Chittenden, Vermont, who claimed to channel spirits and produce ectoplasmic manifestations. The hosts discuss the brothers' abusive childhood, their rise to fame as spiritualist celebrities, and the intense skepticism from figures like Joseph Hall and L.A. Bigelow who accused them of fraud. A key focus is the investigation by skeptical journalist Henry Olcott, who initially sought to debunk the Eddys but became a staunch believer after witnessing their seances. The episode concludes with the brothers' eve…
Topics discussed
Promo: Sheriff Country Season 2
Promo: Other Mommy horror movie
October arrival and time perception
Salem witch trials and book research
Book recommendations and new bookshelf
Introduction to the Eddy Brothers story
Family history and father's abuse
Carnival sideshow years
Opening the Green Tavern and early seances
Sponsor: Oie pet food
Sponsor: State Farm insurance
Civil War era and Mary Todd Lincoln
Growth of fame and outdoor seances
Skeptical investigations and fraud accusations
Specific debunking incidents and reactions
Defenders and letters to the press
Reputation and spiritualism movement
Henry Olcott's background and investigation
Sponsor: Ashley Furniture
Sponsor: Audible
Sponsor: Chamberlain University
Olcott's findings and belief in the brothers
Publication of 'People from the Other World'
Decline of spiritualism and final debunking
Family conflicts and later lives
Modern hauntings and the High Life Ski Club
Conclusion and current state of the lodge
Outro and final thoughts
Sponsor: Instagram teen safety
Listen ad-free on Castria