Morbid Book Club: Killing The Boogeyman by Richard Chizmar
Sep 25, 2026 · 2h 10m
More True Crime podcasts · More Comedy podcasts
Summary
Author Richard Chismar joins the Morbid podcast to discuss his new book, Killing the Boogeyman, the conclusion to his series. The conversation covers the book’s unique true crime style, including the use of realistic photos and the failed attempt to market it as a real case. Chismar also shares personal anecdotes about his childhood fears, his family, and the inspiration behind the story’s small-town setting.
Topics discussed
Sponsorship: Ashley Furniture
Origin story of 'Becoming the Boogeyman'
Reader reactions to the realistic tone
Incorporating crime scene photos into chapters
The failed 'Blair Witch' style marketing plan
Nostalgia for early internet horror marketing
Pranks and neighborhood scares during promotion
The disclaimer and readers Googling the events
Using real-life text messages in the narrative
Childhood storytelling and the boogeyman legend
The Blair Witch basement setting and creepiness
Shared love for horror and haunted houses
Scaring a friend with a spirit summoning prank
Upcoming event with the 'Hanson Road Boys'
Character inspiration from real friend Carly Albright
Writing love scenes and fictionalizing real events
The fear of hidden murderers in daily life
Suburban safety vs. the fragility of life
Parental fear and the 'River Bandman' legend
The rollercoaster nature of being scared
Structure of the sequel and recap articles
Surprise at reader engagement and book sales
Recommendations and the 'Widow's Point' scare
Subtle horror techniques and camera angles
Kids' reactions to horror movies like Return to Oz
Jurassic Park and the fear of de-extinction
Choosing the title 'Killing the Boogeyman'
Childhood mischief and the 'reform school' phase
The whistle signal and strict parenting memories
Realizing the story was about the community
Reflections on the end of the series
How the collaboration with Billy started
Writing styles: Pantser vs. Outliner
The editing process and editor relationships
Overcoming the fear of starting a new book
Vulnerability in using real names and locations
The sledding scene and growing up realization
Early writing habits and emotional depth
The 'Deer by the Train Track' moment
Sponsor break and giving parts of yourself to the world
Neighbors driving by and rubbernecking
Privacy concerns and Karen's awareness
Idea for a horror-themed library stop
Michael Myers references and Halloween nods
Blurring lines with real serial killers like Ramirez
Deciding which mysteries to leave unresolved
Letting the story gain momentum naturally
Why the author avoids reading groups
Scary scenes that affected the author personally
The Gabby Petito case and true crime overlap
Friends' surprise at the dark side of the author
Difficulty processing true crime stories
Impact of crime scene photos on memory
Fiction as a safe space for fear
Stephen King's unsolicited story submission
The beginning of the King-Farrell friendship
King asking Farrell to finish a story
Writing the collaboration and sending it back
Seeing their names side-by-side on NYT list
Gratitude and the concept of a 'gift'
Gratitude for success and hard work
Navigating online negativity with gratitude
King's specific praise for Farrell's style
Comparison of strong women in their lives
Writing the Boogeyman as a living
Would you rather: Time vs. Method of death
Living in the attic and checking latches
Would you rather: Haunted house vs. Murderer
Casper costume and trick-or-treating memories
Planning a family Halloween gathering
Writer's hell: Losing first vs. last 50 pages
Genre classification: Thriller vs. Horror
Dynamic with wife Rich in the books
Would you rather: Unread masterpiece vs. Bad hit
Refreshing memory of character names
Serial killer publicity and trash taking habits
Final question and Swedish candy preference
Release date and pre-order information
Sponsorship: Ashley Furniture
More from Morbid
Listen ad-free on Castria