The Pickwick Club Disaster
Jun 15, 2026 · 47m
Summary
Elena and Ash discuss the 1925 Pickwick Club disaster in Boston, a speakeasy collapse that killed 44 people during a dance. They detail the building's history, the chaotic rescue efforts, and the subsequent manslaughter trials against owners and architects. The hosts highlight the lack of a memorial for the victims and explore the structural failures and rumors surrounding the tragedy.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: Acorn TV, SNHU, and State Farm
Intro: Ash's voice, 'Get it while it's hot' meme
Introduction to the Pickwick Club tragedy
History of the Pickwick Club and its owner Timothy Berry
The club's violent reputation and the fire damage
Sponsors: SimpliSafe, Kotex, and Earnin
The night of the collapse: July 4th, 1928
Rescue efforts and the horrific aftermath
Public reaction and initial blame on overcrowding
Sponsors: Hill's Pet Food and BetterHelp
Investigation: The Charleston vs. structural failure
The trial, acquittals, and lack of a memorial
Reading the names of the 44 victims
Outro: The accidental invention of Play-Doh
Final sponsors: Vyvgart and SoFi
Listen ad-free on Castria