Eileen Zarlenga
Aug 31, 2026 · 1h 51m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the 1988 unsolved murder of Eileen Zarlena in Girard, Ohio, who was found stabbed 27 times after vanishing from her home. Investigators focused on her abusive ex-husband, Nick, who passed a polygraph and was eliminated as the source of oral DNA evidence found in Eileen’s mouth. Despite strong circumstantial evidence and a private investigator’s conviction, the case remains open with no suspect ever charged.
Topics discussed
Introduction to the Criminology podcast
Eileen Zarlena's disappearance in 1988
Discovery of the body and identification
Autopsy findings and Eileen's background
Divorce, financial struggles, and last night out
Sponsor segments for Vinted and DNA Justice
Investigation into ex-husband Nick Zarlena
Missing items and neighbor interviews
Nick's interview and daughter Kristen's account
DNA analysis and early suspect elimination
Case goes cold and initial media coverage
Case reopens in 2000s and 2010s
PI Duke Snyder's theory and cowboy boot evidence
New witness Kim and Nick's 2011 interview
Investigation into suspect Chip and DNA testing
DNA database challenges and lab accreditation issues
DNA deconvolution and phenotypic profiling
Genealogical breakthrough identifying Ernest Dickerson
DNA confirmation and interview with son Dex
Theories on the killer and case conclusion
More from DNA: ID
Listen ad-free on Castria