Saad Kawaf Part 2 of 2
Oct 26, 2026 · 1h 8m
More True Crime podcasts
Summary
This episode details the resolution of the 1999 Saad Kowaf murder, solved using genetic genealogy to identify former Jacksonville Sheriff's Office detective William Baer and his ex-wife, Melissa Schaefer. Baer exploited his inside knowledge from a money laundering investigation to plan the armed robbery and murder with Schaefer. The narrative covers the forensic breakthroughs, the arrests, and Schaefer’s subsequent guilty plea in exchange for testifying against Baer, who eventually pleaded guilty to first-degree murder to avoid the death penalty.
Topics discussed
Case background and initial DNA testing efforts
Genetic genealogy identifies male suspect William Baer
Conflict of interest: Baer investigated the victim
Identifying female suspect and collecting Baer's DNA
Surveillance and DNA collection from Schaefer's trash
Arrests and initial interviews of Baer and Schaefer
Schaefer's confession and subsequent suicide attempt
Press conference and family reactions to the arrests
Backgrounds of the suspects and legal charges filed
Schaefer's plea deal and evidence linking Baer to the crime
Baer's guilty plea and victim impact statements
Contradictions in Baer's service record and sentencing
Schaefer's sentencing hearing and personal statement
Prosecution's argument and Schaefer's final sentence
Connection to the Sammy Safar corruption case
Closing thoughts and podcast support information
More from DNA: ID
Listen ad-free on Castria